Not one to miss the latest coconut trend, I have been indulging in my share of coconut water, milk, oil and of course, coquito.
Coquito is a Puerto Rican alcoholic beverage typically served during the holiday season. It’s often compared to Egg Nog but my latest take on the drink is nothing like the thick and heavy recipes that crowd the internet. My family isn’t much for tradition, so Coquito is served year round at all gatherings. Its history doesn’t run deep with us either, no one in the family taught me how to make it. I simply decided to make it and found a super easy recipe on Google.
A can of coconut milk, a can of this, a dash of that, rum and voilà. The basic recipe has been going over well enough for the past couple of years but I decided to kick it up a notch. I have now discovered the most amazingly fresh Coquito and want to share my labor with you. It’s fun to make, tasty and even better to share.
Begin with a few fresh coconuts. Whole Foods and Harvest Time down the street from Lincoln Square carry them. This video shows an amazingly easy way of splitting a coconut with the back of a knife.
Scrape the coconut meat into a blender and puree with enough of the coconut water to make a light paste. It doesn’t have to be silky smooth, that’s part of the appeal. It’s best to err on the thicker side since more can always be added later. Set aside.
Heat 1 1/2 cups whole milk and 1/2 cup raw sugar together in a sauce pan on low until about half of the liquid is reduced. Then finish with 3 Tbs butter and 1 tsp vanilla extract. Now you have homemade sweetened condensed milk.
Mix in some sweetened condensed milk with the coconut mixture. Don’t pour it all in since exact measurements are useless in this scenario. Each coconut is going to have its own yield of meat so using your senses will result in a far better product than any arbitrary measurements I could provide. Just do lots of taste tests!
Now add Puerto Rican rum, cinnamon and cloves. Refrigerate and serve cold in a sherry glass with a dash of nutmeg.
This drink can be labor intensive, but I find that to make the best coquito, the freshness is necessary. It also makes for a light dessert that can be enjoyed year round.









